sharpnova's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Madness Hydraulic]

It was ok

Nothing new or special, but it had some problems:

-what's the point of upgrading your fist attack if you can't stop yourself from picking up weapons when they land near you?
-lag in later waves
-turrets were pretty much useless in later waves
-completely unoriginal

The visuals/sound were great.

Also, it's not your fault but a lot of your submissions get overrated just because you're Tom. I'm not saying this isn't front page material. But people are being too forgiving of some of this game's fundamental flaws.

[Scene of the crime: GD]

one really annoying thing

Awesome game but there was one major annoyance.

The inventory. The icons should glow or grow when you hover over them but not move. It's annoying chasing down the things I want to click.

[My First Quantum Translocator]

masterpiece.

[Death Row Diner]

my one complaint

it's passable and smooth. no bugs that i can see. but achieving expert scores is way too difficult. i would play a particularly flawless round with brilliant chaining and ridicu-efficient queuing of actions and end up with 1/2 or 1/3 of the expert score. stupid.

[Harmony Keeper]

unclear

though the game had tons of potential to be fun, descriptions were too vague.. and the english was too terrible to really know what anything did.

that one upgrade you could buy with skill points called "recover mana" made absolutely no sense. what did that do?

what did upgrading your guardians on the battlefield do?

[Pixelotl]

clumsy and lacking content

no music detracted from any type of immersion

clumsy movement and strange collision detection made the overall experience unejoyable.

there wasn't really anything i liked about this game.

[Air Transporter]

terrible

terrible absolutely terrible controls. on level 1 i gave up and suddenly my helicopter was holding the thing. i kept lowering my ropes onto the box.. over and over.. and they simply wouldn't attach.

i ended up at lvl 6 and decided this game was not worth my time.

[Collateral]

far farout of context.

it's nice for a 48-hour project.. but why is it on the front page? i assumed the front page was based on overall game quality.. not "game quality given that etc."

my rating to you is based on its front page status.

if this were a 48-hour project flash game website, then my rating would be higher.

MrPiglet responds:

I didn't choose to put it up there, but whatever, I don't want special dispensation for making it quickly either.

What would you have liked me to have done better? (so that next time I can make something more worthy :)

[One Button Bob]

pretty fun

97 clicks on 2nd try. first try was 104

[Morplee]

bad game for the ads

when you force us to watch a commercial, you put yourself in THAT category of game. and for games that are worth watching a commercial for, yours is quite bad.

with normal ads, this would have been a 10/10. you chose your category.